Intro
Two former planning chairs sit down to take apart what has gone wrong with London’s planning system and why Southwark’s recent decisions on the Aylesham Centre and Borough Triangle sit at the heart of it. Nick Dolezal brings a rare perspective. He was there when Southwark was pro-development, market-led and building things. He was there when the Shard was initiated, when Tate Modern opened on Bankside, and when Elephant and Castle, Bermondsey Spa and Canada Water were set in motion. He watched the political culture shift from drawing down benefits from the market to using housing policy as ideology, and watched that shift eventually consume two major Berkeley schemes that the planning system spent a decade chewing over before spitting out. The conversation moves from the Parkhurst Road judgment and what the GLA made of it, through the community pressure and political escalation that shaped the Aylesham Centre process, to the planning committee culture that Nick Cuff argues has turned a permissive regime into a social housing checkpoint. And it ends with a question nobody in planning wants to answer: if you won’t grant at 12% and the viability evidence says the maximum achievable is zero, what exactly are you waiting for?
Key Takeaways
- Southwark under Jeremy Fraser from 1994 was deliberately market-led and pro-development, a political break from what Nick describes as the ‘oppressive old Labour, anti-development’ culture that preceded it.
- The Parkhurst judgment and the GLA’s interpretation of it transformed planning from a negotiated process into what Nick Dolezal calls a tariff, with planning obligations on a £550,000 property running to around £120,000.
- The Aylesham Centre and Borough Triangle refusals are the culmination of a decade of deliberation, escalating community demands and narrowing room for negotiation. Nick believes a deal at 35% affordable housing was achievable earlier in the process.
- Nick argues that heritage objections at Aylesham were refined by an organised network of local campaigners and that similar arguments were then used in the Borough Triangle debate.
- Planning committees have increasingly become social housing champions, with developers and committees both constrained by policies set above them.
- The systemic options discussed are to reject schemes below policy thresholds, provide more government grant for subsidised housing, or separate social housing delivery from private development obligations.
- The viability crunch is not confined to London. Berlin, Melbourne and Sydney face similar challenges.