Home / Housing delivery / Black Swans Part 5: Budgets, Iran and Deadlock, Capital Light and Capital Tight

Black Swans Part 5: Budgets, Iran and Deadlock, Capital Light and Capital Tight

Straits of Hormuz

Whilst the UK Budget had some interesting tit bits, PropViews has been spending more time considering the standoff between Iran and the USA and what this all means for UK real estate.  Alas, we are mid Black Swan.  And Black Swans are bigger than Budgets.  Here’s my take on how this all links back.

Soundings

The Financial Times of late has become a public channel for US and Iranian foreign policy utterances.   Mike Waltz, US Ambassador to the UN on the 23rd October told the FT  that the United States was prepared for a prolonged confrontation, potentially lasting another year or longer.

His principal messages were the blockade could continue indefinitely.  That Washington was prepared to maintain its blockade of Iranian ports and intensify economic sanctions.  Iran must make nuclear concessions. The US wanted Iran’s highly enriched nuclear material removed and restrictions on domestic uranium enrichment.

Following Mr Waltz’s comments, Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s Foreign Minister, wrote an opinion article in the FT setting out Iran’s position.  His points were that whilst Iran wanted a deal, trust with Washington had gone.  They were willing to accept a truce to find a deal but there were no immediate concessions on offer.

Battlelines

Lines have hardened since the MoU collapsed back in the summer.   The US wants removal of what it terms ‘the nuclear dust’ or enriched uranium from Iran and Iran absolutely refuses to countenance such an action.

It does appear that an economic blockade in the short term is going to do more harm to Iran than it will to the US.  The US despite the mid-terms will not change its position under this Presidency.

With Iran, the situation does sound extremely bad with severe inflation and economic contraction.  Recently oil loadings fell to zero and the remaining oil stored aboard tankers in Asian waters depleted two weeks ago.

This means the trickle of foreign earnings from oil sales to countries such as China has now halted.   Iran is a huge country and one which I’d imagine is expensive to run.  How this will impact on its internal affairs is highly speculative.  The US thinks it will have a significant impact.  However, history tells us that terrible regimes tend to last longer than most people imagine.

Deadlock and back to the UK

So whether any of this will translate into a deal is far from certain.  We are now in what could be described as a lengthy deadlock, and such a deadlock is bad news for countries such as the UK which are highly dependent on energy importations.

When the war started, everyone hoped that a swift war would not do too much harm to the world economic health.  Predictions were that if the war lasted more than two months, we would start to see a rise in the hard costs of construction by around 10% in the UK.  Unfortunately, we are now way past that point.

The costs of war

The war is having three impacts.  The first is cost inflation as energy prices remain elevated.  Diesal has tipped over £2 a litre.

The second is cost of capital.  Higher inflation elevates capital costs.  Third are transmission effects.  Global capital funds will be retrenching, particularly Middle Eastern capital which will now potentially be returned to repair infrastructure damaged from drone and other various missile attacks.

Are we running out of investment capital?

Two weeks ago, on the popular All In podcast, the hosts speculated whether with another billion dollar IPO on the very near horizon, whether the world would just not have the investment capital to power the AI revolution.  The big blockage is compute and compute requires enormous capex spend.   They concluded that with paybacks around 12 to 18 months, the capital reservoir would not be exhausted anytime soon.  Good news for them and those in the AI world.

But whilst listeners invested in tech and AI will of course be heartened to hear that prognosis, if like me you are working in property development you will troubled.  Capital is moving and it is finding better investment returns.

Housing development in global cities like London is no longer an exciting capital allocation.  It is contentious, elongated, obscure and rarely returns at the rate that capital needs to make the investment worthwhile.  And Black Swans which elevate hard costs don’t help much either.

Prolonged war is killing large projects

Policy makers can no longer take for granted that investment capital is there to back UK plc on the current terms.   After the decisions of Taylor Wimpey to fully exit the  Greater London region and LandSecs to mothball its major Lewisham towncentre regeneration, PropViews predicted a further three major private investment regeneration schemes would be exited in the next six months.

One announced almost immediately, British Land’s Canada Water.  Expect at least another two as private capital moves from a stage withdrawal to a stampede from the London development market.   The age of enforcement is failing and black swans bites.

Capital is tight

The UK Government can clearly see that capital is constrained and so the Budget has topped up the allocation on social housing.  Another £1.5 bn was tipped in which represents a 7.5% uplift on the current programme through to the end of this Parliament.

In better times, UK Plc could take a more activist approach at this point in the cycle to protect supply.  Unfortunately, we are not in better times and whilst the £1.5 bn is welcome it’s simply not enough.

We know that money is tight from the grant allocations drama which has been rippling around London and other parts of the UK.  The Government has shunted the allocation towards Councils and this has led to many RSLs being hamstrung and short of what they need.

With many schemes drip dependent on public subsidy even just to breakeven, there was hope of a significant capital injection from Government to prop up the ailing development pipeline both in London and elsewhere.  Unfortunately this has not worked out and the £1.5 bn doesn’t touch the sides.

Many RPs with shovel ready schemes did not get anything like what they were expecting and some had zero grant allocations.  In London, there is approximately £4.7 bn of capital unallocated, this is being rationed to manage performance.  In a crisis is that the right approach?

For more on the Black Swan series see the earlier parts here:

Black Swans and the Planning System: Why Profit Caps Don’t Work in Housing – PropViews

Black Swans, Bond Markets and the Housing Pipeline – Part 2 – PropViews

Black swans, cost inflation and the London Mayor is now King – Part 3 – PropViews

Black Swans, Transmission Impacts and Ceasefires – Part 4 – PropViews

 

Nick Cuff

Nick created propviews in 2018 to bridge the knowledge gap between policy and practice in housebuilding. He is an entrepreneur and property developer with a passion for place making and the positive role the built environment can play in transforming communities. Nick has played a key role in a number of London’s private/public partnerships over the last two decades working across both large scale masterplan proposals and smaller, infill sites.

Read full bio →