Home / Housing delivery / London housebuilding is collapsing, but who is listening?

London housebuilding is collapsing, but who is listening?

Cranes

Posted in:

London has almost stopped building homes, and it has barely registered in politics. Molior reports that in September and October this year developers applied for planning permission for just 754 homes. In the same months of 2016, it was 17,683, a 96% fall in a decade.

The consequences of London’s supply collaspe

Private capital is pulling out because of higher build costs, regulatory delays and a flatlining market have made residential development too risky for the returns on offer. Some firms still operating in London are being pushed out by councils demanding ever more Affordable Housing, built at a loss. Tens of thousands of people used to work on London’s housing sites each day; now the figure is in the thousands.

The result is a city that struggles even more to house the people who live in it or want to move to it. Londoners make do with ever smaller spaces at ever higher costs, and many are being priced out altogether .  Last year, London’s population shrank for the first time since 1988 excluding the pandemic.

For a city whose competitiveness rests so heavily on its dense labour market, a steady drain of workers who leave, or never come, is slowly eroding what makes London work.  Other global cities are watching and starting to catch up.

The politics of housing

Jobs and living standards decide elections, and improving them is why most people go into politics. Yet the politicians who have overseen the shrivelling of homebuilding in the capital have faced few consequences at the ballot box. Some Londoners need social homes, but policy is now made as if they were the only homes that matter.

Often, it feels like our political leaders have forgotten the three-quarters of London households, and almost nine in ten working households, who rely on the private market for a home. It is a strange political dynamic.

Part of the problem is how the issue is talked about. The industry wants to talk about how to make schemes viable. Local politicians are more comfortable arguing that new private homes are not affordable to their voters. Central government talks about tough choices to deliver 1.5 million homes, but London has been an afterthought, despite needing to deliver three in ten of the targeted homes. The emergency package agreed by ministers and the Mayor last year has not moved the market, because it did cut the cost of development far enough.

Developers and employers need to organise

For developers, how housing is talked about might feel a long way from the day job of making schemes stack up. But it is an important reason why so many schemes no longer work. Policymakers have piled on costs and restrictions because each one seemed popular, or at least looked free, when it was made. The price is paid years later, by the people who needed the homes that never got built.

London will only start building again when its leaders want it to, and the industry has to make the case in terms they care about: jobs, schools, and the cost of living for their voters. It has to convince London’s politicians that more homes help meet the many other demands they juggle.

The case will land best when it comes from the people hit hardest by the shortage. Headteachers are watching pupil rolls fall and schools close as fewer young families can afford to live nearby. Universities struggle to attract and retain researchers. Nurses and firefighters, whom Londoners rely on in an emergency, commute for hours each day. Few will ever be offered a social home, they rent privately or hope to buy.

For employers, high housing costs push up wages without raising productivity, making London a more expensive place to do business. The press wants to run these stories, and nobody can dismiss them as special pleading. Their case has to be made directly to politicians and kept up in the press and on social media, not just through bursts of activity.

London’s Mayoral Candidates

The aim should be to get every London mayoral candidate to commit not just to a number of homes, but to the changes that would get them built, like removing some of the policies that have inflated build costs. It should also be to persuade the Treasury that London needs a market for new homes as well as an easier route to building them. That means looking again at taxes on buying homes, especially those that drove overseas buyers and smaller landlords out of the market. Off-plan sales to these buyers are what let developers raise the finance to start building.

Every year of low homebuilding leaves London’s economy poorer and less competitive. As workers squeeze into less space or leave the city altogether, productivity and living standards fall, and so does the prosperity of a country that relies on its capital. The next London Plan, future fiscal events and the May 2028 mayoral election will set the city’s housing policy into the 2030s. Those who need London to build more homes, from developers to the schools, universities and employers that need people to be able to live nearby, have to make their case now.

Jack Airey

Jack Airey is a Director at Public First, a research and strategy consultancy. He previously served two Prime Ministers as a Special Adviser at 10 Downing Street, where he helped shape the Government's housing, planning, and levelling up agenda. He writes on how policymaking meets politics, and how to shape reform that industry can get behind.

Read full bio →